CURRENT FOCUS
as a father i have to be honest about the thing nobody has said yet, i live in a country where school emergencies are not hypothetical and when my daughter texted me "we are hiding, i love you" two years ago during a false alarm, that text was the worst and most important message of my life, you can tell me about front office protocols all day but you will not convince a parent that being unreachable during those forty minutes is acceptable, i am sorry, on everything else i am with the teachers but not this
— david.figueroa
Helpful 0Credible 0Clear 0Important 0
On this claim: Against is leadingFor 1 · Against 2Local to this claim · based on the number of people engaged (not a percentage)
SUMMARY
No summary yet.
Against（2）
In safety engineering we design one clear channel, not eight hundred parallel ones. An evacuation with everyone broadcasting is called noise, and noise costs minutes. The school's channel to parents must be fast and trusted — that is the fix. The individual phones are not redundancy, they are interference.
— eng.paula
David, I've been through two real lockdowns, and I'm going to say the hard thing: the phones made both worse. Kids texting rumors that outran the facts, ringtones in silent rooms, and 400 parents arriving at a sealed building mid-incident. Every safety officer who's briefed us says the same: eyes on the adult, not the screen. I carry your fear too — I just don't think the phone answers it.
— ms.harmon
Click any claim to drill into the arguments for and against it.
Please log in to post.